Lyle's

Enjoy authentic local flavors at Lyle's Pizza in Evansville, IN. Savor delicious stromboli, pigskin pizza, and hot ham & cheese, while relaxing with live music, karaoke, and a smoking bar. Experience the welcoming honky tonk vibe today!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Lyle's

Taste the Difference.

Lyle's
Lyle's
Lyle's
Lyle's

Lyle's Pizza Restaurant, located at 1404 E Morgan Ave in Evansville, offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for pizza lovers and those seeking a lively social scene. Here, the aroma of freshly baked stromboli and handmade pizzas fills the air, inviting patrons to indulge. The vibrant community feel is hard to miss, especially when live music resonates through the halls and laughter echoes around the pool table.

Visitors rave about the authentic Philly cheesesteak and the famous pigskin pizza. Whether you pop in for a quick lunch or a night out with friends, Lyle's promises great food and great times. With karaoke nights and honky tonk vibes, every visit brings a new experience. Don't forget to check your calendar; Saturday night is the hottest spot in town.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1404 E Morgan Ave, Evansville, IN 47711, United States

Phone

+1 812-425-7729

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Lyle's
Lyle's
Lyle's
Lyle's

Lyle's Pizza Restaurant is more than just a place to grab a bite; it is a hub for the Evansville community. Known for its friendly service and inviting atmosphere, Lyle's takes pride in serving up quality meals that cater to a variety of tastes. From its noteworthy stromboli to its crowd-pleasing pizzas, each dish is crafted with care and passion. The restaurant accommodates both dine-in and carry-out options, allowing customers the freedom to enjoy their meals wherever they please.

Lyle's is not just about food but is an inclusive gathering space that hosts events like karaoke and live music, bringing patrons together for shared experiences and social connections. Saturday nights shine bright at Lyle's, and its reputation as the go-to spot in Evansville is well-deserved. Regulars flock to enjoy their favorite dishes, while live acts keep the atmosphere electric. The commitment to the local feel enhances the dining experience, making diners feel like part of a larger family. Whether it’s a casual meal with friends or a lively celebration, Lyle's checks all the boxes for an engaging night out.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday3-11 PM
  • Monday3-11 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-11 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-11 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-11 PM
  • Friday11 AM-3 AM
  • Saturday11 AM-1:30 AM

Lyle's stands out with its diverse menu and engaging ambiance. The restaurant features an extensive list of delicious toppings and platters, marrying traditional favorites with unique creations. Menu options like the Lyleboli and Tailgate Grill Items invite options for everyone. Additionally, Lyle's boasts a smoking bar, facilitating an enjoyable environment for those who prefer it. Karaoke nights bring a lively spirit, where guests can unleash their inner rock stars. The well-placed pool table offers a fun distraction for groups looking to unwind while enjoying great food. Expect a friendly atmosphere where regulars and new faces mingle, embodying the community spirit that Lyle's fosters.

Lyle's

Lyle's captures the essence of a local gem with its unpretentious exterior and homey vibe. The inviting storefront encourages walk-ins, and the outdoor seating gives diners a chance to soak in the atmosphere as they enjoy their meals. The vibrant signage hints at the laughter and music inside, beckoning pizza enthusiasts to join in. The overall vibe feels laid-back and welcoming, where locals quickly become familiar faces. It’s a place where laughter and camaraderie flourish, making every visit feel like a homecoming.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Looking for a replacement for pizza king stroms? Well here ya go! Just as big, and even better than words can describe! I would place the pizza on par or above the una pizzas in town, and appetizers are excellent as well. With a super friendly staff, you've got a winner of a place! Keep up the great work guys, it's noticed!

B
Bill K.

A special little place to enjoy talented local musicians while having some great food with great company. Check out the Facebook page for upcoming bands and events.

C
Carrie H.

Excellent stromboli, made fresh while I waited!! Good cold beer, and an excellent bar tender!! The tenderloin was excellent and fresh as well!!

A
April M.

Great little dive with good food, service and lovely regulars. No frills and affordable for a little night out.

c
clint h.

Love this place. Been coming here for years! Bartenders are great. Music is great! Food is best ever! Love the new menus and the hometown neighborhood tavern vibe. Outstanding

K
Karol M.

We had a BLAST! We're from St. Louis MO area and were in Evansville for me to have surgery. We just so happened to pass Lyle's whole. Looking for a place to get my hair braided and after looking at pics of the food on Google we decided to give it a shot! Absolutely thrilled we did. The had live music (right up our alley), good drinks, great food and jusg a good vibe/energy the whole time we were there No regrets: Food: OUTSTANDING Service: AMAZING (unfortunately didn't catch the bartenders name but we were there 4/10/25) Atmosphere: fantastic! Will be back on one of the days I have to come back to Evansville for a follow up

C
Courtney F.